Lemon Drops Source: Delicious Homemade Candy Recipes 11. Shaggy Dogs Source: Shaggy Dogs Candy Recipe 16. Maple Syrup Candy Source: Maple Syrup Candy Recipe 17. Peanut Candy Bars Source: Homemade Pay Day Candy Bars 21. Copycat Almond Joy Candy Bar Source: frugalcouponliving.com 24.